עברית
Creativity Value, PR agency in Israel

How to Choose a PR Agency for Your Startup: 10 Questions to Ask

Choosing a PR agency is one of the first marketing decisions a founder makes, and one of the hardest to judge from the outside. Proposals look similar, every agency promises top-tier coverage, and the real differences only show up three months into the work. This guide gives founders a practical way to compare PR agencies for startups before signing.

In short

  • Hire for understanding of your product and market, not for the size of the agency.
  • Ask who will actually do the work and who will speak with reporters.
  • Agree on goals and reporting before the first press release.
  • A good startup PR agency says no to weak stories.

72%
of journalists say fewer than a quarter of the pitches they receive are relevant
66%
rely on PR content for story ideas
$5,000 to $10,000
typical US monthly retainer for seed to Series A startups
3.4%
average response rate to PR pitches

When does a startup need a PR agency?

PR works when there is a real story to tell. The usual triggers are a funding round, a product launch, entry into a new market, a significant customer, or the need to recruit a team quickly. If none of these is on the horizon, a short consulting project on messaging is often a better first step than a monthly retainer.

The 10 questions

#QuestionWhat a good answer sounds like
1Which startups at our stage have you worked with?Specific names, stages and results, with references you can call
2Who will work on our account day to day?Named people, including a senior lead who joins the calls
3How well do you understand our technology?They explain your product back to you in plain language
4Which reporters cover our category?Names of reporters and what they wrote recently
5What is our story, in your opinion?A clear angle, and honest feedback on what is not newsworthy
6What will the first 90 days look like?A plan with milestones, not a list of services
7How do you measure success?Target outlets, message delivery and business signals, not only clip counts
8How do you combine PR with LinkedIn and podcasts?A joined-up plan for executive visibility
9What do you need from us?Access to founders, data, customers and fast approvals
10What happens if the story does not land?A plan B, and transparency about what went wrong

Boutique agency or large firm?

Boutique agency
  • Senior people do the work
  • Faster decisions and approvals
  • Deep focus on a few sectors
  • Best for seed to growth-stage startups
Large firm
  • Broad coverage of many markets
  • Larger teams and more process
  • Useful for multi-country programs
  • Best for late-stage and public companies

A simple selection process

STEP 1
Define the goal
Investors, customers, talent or all three.
STEP 2
Shortlist three
Agencies that know your sector and market.
STEP 3
Ask the ten questions
Same questions to each, compare answers.
STEP 4
Check references
Speak with two current or past clients.
STEP 5
Start with 90 days
Agree on milestones and review together.

Red flags

  • Guaranteed coverage in a specific outlet.
  • A proposal that could have been written for any company.
  • No questions about your business goals.
  • Senior people in the pitch, junior people on the account.
  • Reporting that counts clips and ignores impact.

Startups in Israel

For startups based in Israel, or foreign startups working with the Israeli ecosystem, local media relations and a clear Hebrew and English story are essential. Read more about our PR services for startups and tech PR.

Why the choice of agency matters: what journalists report

Cision’s 2026 survey of 1,899 journalists found that 66% rely on PR content for story ideas, so a good agency is a real route into the news. The same survey found that 72% of journalists consider fewer than a quarter of the pitches they receive relevant, and 82% reject pitches because they do not fit their audience. A separate analysis of about 400,000 pitches put the average response rate at 3.4%.

The relevance gap (Cision, State of the Media 2026)

Reject pitches that do not fit their audience82%
Say under a quarter of pitches are relevant72%
Rely on PR content for story ideas66%
Object to AI-generated pitches53%

The difference between an agency that gets replies and one that does not is rarely creativity. It is knowing which reporter covers what, and saying no to stories that will not land. That is what the ten questions above are designed to test.

What startups pay: published ranges

StagePublished monthly range (US)Source
Pre-seed, freelance consultant$3,000 to $5,000Stackmatix, 2026
Seed to Series A$5,000 to $10,000Everything-PR, 2026
Series A$8,000 to $15,000AMW, 2026
Growth stage and pre-IPO$25,000 to $40,000 or moreEverything-PR, 2026

Fees in Israel are generally lower than these US ranges. Our PR pricing guide compares published figures for the US, the UK and Israel.

A scorecard for comparing agencies

CriterionWeightHow to score it
Understanding of your product and market25%Did they explain your product back to you correctly?
Relevant media relationships20%Did they name reporters and recent stories in your field?
Seniority of the working team20%Who will write, pitch and join your calls?
Quality of the proposed story15%Is the angle specific, and did they challenge weak ideas?
Process and reporting10%Is there a 90-day plan with clear milestones?
References10%What did two current or former clients say?

Score each agency from one to five on every line, multiply by the weight and compare. The exercise takes an hour and removes most of the guesswork.

Frequently asked questions

How long should the first contract be?

Three to six months is common. It is long enough to see results and short enough to change course.

Can a startup do PR without an agency?

Yes, at a very early stage. Founders can build relationships with a few reporters directly. An agency adds value when the volume and stakes grow.

Should we hire an agency before funding is announced?

Ideally four to six weeks before the announcement, so the story and the exclusive can be prepared properly.

Planning PR in Israel?

Creativity Value is a local PR agency for startups and international companies entering the Israeli market.

Talk to us